Go Back
Old-fashioned peanut butter pie with creamy peanut butter filling in a pastry crust

Mom Mom Marlin's Famous Peanut Butter Pie

An old-fashioned custard pie served at Marlin's Restaurant in Altoona, Pennsylvania.
This recipe was passed down from my grandmother, whom we called Mom Mom Marlin. She was known for her wonderful homemade pies at Marlin's Restaurant in Altoona, Pennsylvania.
The measurements and directions have been preserved as they were shared with our family. Like many old-fashioned recipes, some details were left to the cook's experience. This is a treasured family keepsake, and the preparation method has not yet been independently tested.
Servings: 1 Pie
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American

Ingredients
  

  • 2 cups milk
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • 3 egg yolks beaten
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla
  • 3 tablespoons cornstarch
  • Water enough to mix with the cornstarch
  • Approximately 1 cup peanut butter to taste
  • 1 prebaked pie crust

Method
 

  1. Original family instructions
    Mix the milk, sugar, beaten egg yolks, salt, and vanilla together. Heat, but do not boil.
    Mix the cornstarch with water until it reaches a thicker consistency. The original instructions say to cool it, then add it to the mixture.
    Add peanut butter to taste, approximately 1 cup.
    Stir and add to an already baked pie crust.
  2. - Original family instructions
  3. Mix the milk, sugar, beaten egg yolks, salt, and vanilla together. Heat, but do not boil.
  4. Mix the cornstarch with water until it reaches a thicker consistency. The original instructions say to cool it, then add it to the mixture.
  5. Add peanut butter to taste, approximately 1 cup.
  6. Stir and add to an already baked pie crust.

Notes

This recipe was passed down from my grandmother, whom we called Mom Mom Marlin. She was known for her wonderful homemade pies at Marlin's Restaurant in Altoona, Pennsylvania.
The measurements and directions have been preserved as they were shared with our family. Like many old-fashioned recipes, some details were left to the cook's experience. This is a treasured family keepsake, and the preparation method has not yet been independently tested.